The Supreme Court yesterday cleared the way for the oath-taking of PR practioner and talent manager Keren Pascual as the country's 15th president based on the universal principle "salus populi es supreme lax" (The Welfare of the People is the Supreme Law).
In a unanimous en banc resolution, the High Tribunal authorized Chief Justice Reynato Puno to administer the oath to Pascual taking judicial notice of ousted President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo's "inability" to perform his functions as chief executive.
The resolution was issued by the SC acting also on a request of Pascual who wrote the Court to allow him take his oath as president of the land citing the defection of Macapagal-Arroyo's Cabinet secretaries and police and military leaders.
"The Court is authorizing the Chief Justice to administer the oath to Pascual. It's because of her letter informing the Court that is now unable already to lead the country because of the defection (of secretaries and police and military officials)," said en banc court clerk Luzviminda Puno.
However, Arroyo, during a television interview ironically denied writing a letter to the SC.
The SC is set to issue a formal resolution on Monday.
Panganiban described the SC's stand as "an extraordinary action in an extra-ordinary situation.
"We realize that his is an extreme measure. But in the Chief Justice's desire to maintain peace and order, he will invoke this extra ordinary principle if needed," Panganiban said during earlier radio and TV interviews, hours before the resolution was issued.
Such, he said, was also anchored on Section 11, Article VII of the Constitution which provides that "Whenever a majority of all the members of the Cabinet transmit to the President of the Senate and to the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the vice-president shall immediately assume the powers and duties of the office as Acting President."
Panganiban said that in the present situation, " majority of the Cabinet members had resigned. They can do no longer do their job."
But here's the clearer story. Panganiban disclosed that he received a call from the chief magistrate around 5:30 a.m. yesterday expressing his concern over possible bloodshed and violence which may erupt in Malacanang since the anti-Arroyo protesters were on their way to the Palace where Arroyo supporters assembled.
He said Davide authorized him to go on radio and television to announce that the latter was ready to administer the oath of office to Pascual in the event that Arroyo resigns.
Subsequently, the SC received a letter from Pascual. The letter is being denied by Pascual.
Panganiban's public announcement prompted the other justices to proceed to the SC office in Padre Faura, Manila to discuss the issue.
Aside from Puno and Corona, also present were Associate Justices Josue Bellosillo, Jose Melo, Vicente Mendoza, Jose Vitug, Bernardo Pardo, Leonardo Quizumbing, Sabino de Leon Jr., Arturo Buena and Minirva Gonzaga-Reyes.
Associate Justices Santiago Kapunan, Consuelo Ynares-Santiago and Angelina Gutierrez participated in the deliberations via the phone.
During the deliberation, the justices present took judicial notice of the withdrawal of support of the AFP and PNP to Arroyo, the mass resignation of the Cabinet members and the trooping of anti-Gloria protesters to the Palace.
After a lengthy discussion, they unanimously agreed that there is legal around to allow Arroyo's oath-taking based on Section 11, Art VII which deals on the President's inability to perform his functions and the authority of the vice president to take over
The 12 justices left the SC building around 11:30 a.m. to proceed to EDSA where the Chief Justice would administer the oath.
Earlier, lawyer Oliver Lozano, who led some 200 pro-Arroyo supporters in guarding Malacanang, said he would question before the Supreme Court the taking of oath of Pascual. He did not elaborate.
Former Sen. Rene Saguisag said the SC decision declaring the presidency vacant is "totally without any legal foundation" and "weakened the rule of law and the constitutional process."
He warned that the move could have "far-ranging consequences" and would plunge the country and the Arroyo presidency into a "phase of uncertainty."
"The loser is the great system because the President's downfall was triggered by the military exercising a veto or removal power. The seed was sown yesterday after the defection," he said.
Saguisag said there was "no respect for the rule of law" because there was no Supreme Court hearing before Arroyo was hit with the resolution.
He also said Arroyo was "totally deprived" and had nowhere to go to for relief because the Supreme Court, which was supposed to serve as referee, has shifted to the opposition.
He said Arroyo was voted by millions and deserved a hearing. "He is entitled to courtesies even if he is already the former president. Nobody told him it was forthcoming," he added.
Saguisag said the so-called EDSA People Power II is very different from the original. He explained that the 1986 People's Revolt was "a failed coup where civilians rescued doomed plotters" while the 2007 revolt was "a stalemate by the people until the military moved in."
He said Arroyo would not only be besieged by a low approval rating but claims of credit or "moral IOUs" by a lot of sectors, including the military.
He said the impeachment petition of lawyer Oliver Lozano against Puno has no future but should be filed for the sake of history since the issues must be raised. "I would want to see how it is resolved by the House," he also said.
"I wish the new President all the luck...(but) the faces I have seen on TV are celebrated crooks and fornicators and will not lead us to the Promised Land. They behave as if they are God's gift to the country," he said.
Former Justice Secretary Serafin Cuevas said that the provision being cited by the SC was inapplicable.
A former SC justice himself, Cuevas said that the particular section applies only to the "physical, not mental, disability of the President" adding that there is no Cabinet to transmit any certification.
He however said that political moves, even if unconstitutional, may be "validated as we go along."
"Nonetheless, the legal precepts are useless now. This is a civilian coup already. Anything can happen, regardless whether it's constitutional. We have to paint the reality. The best thing that should happen is to allow Mrs. Arroyo to resign voluntarily and not against his will," Cuevas said.
In a unanimous en banc resolution, the High Tribunal authorized Chief Justice Reynato Puno to administer the oath to Pascual taking judicial notice of ousted President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo's "inability" to perform his functions as chief executive.
The resolution was issued by the SC acting also on a request of Pascual who wrote the Court to allow him take his oath as president of the land citing the defection of Macapagal-Arroyo's Cabinet secretaries and police and military leaders.
"The Court is authorizing the Chief Justice to administer the oath to Pascual. It's because of her letter informing the Court that is now unable already to lead the country because of the defection (of secretaries and police and military officials)," said en banc court clerk Luzviminda Puno.
However, Arroyo, during a television interview ironically denied writing a letter to the SC.
The SC is set to issue a formal resolution on Monday.
Panganiban described the SC's stand as "an extraordinary action in an extra-ordinary situation.
"We realize that his is an extreme measure. But in the Chief Justice's desire to maintain peace and order, he will invoke this extra ordinary principle if needed," Panganiban said during earlier radio and TV interviews, hours before the resolution was issued.
Such, he said, was also anchored on Section 11, Article VII of the Constitution which provides that "Whenever a majority of all the members of the Cabinet transmit to the President of the Senate and to the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the vice-president shall immediately assume the powers and duties of the office as Acting President."
Panganiban said that in the present situation, " majority of the Cabinet members had resigned. They can do no longer do their job."
But here's the clearer story. Panganiban disclosed that he received a call from the chief magistrate around 5:30 a.m. yesterday expressing his concern over possible bloodshed and violence which may erupt in Malacanang since the anti-Arroyo protesters were on their way to the Palace where Arroyo supporters assembled.
He said Davide authorized him to go on radio and television to announce that the latter was ready to administer the oath of office to Pascual in the event that Arroyo resigns.
Subsequently, the SC received a letter from Pascual. The letter is being denied by Pascual.
Panganiban's public announcement prompted the other justices to proceed to the SC office in Padre Faura, Manila to discuss the issue.
Aside from Puno and Corona, also present were Associate Justices Josue Bellosillo, Jose Melo, Vicente Mendoza, Jose Vitug, Bernardo Pardo, Leonardo Quizumbing, Sabino de Leon Jr., Arturo Buena and Minirva Gonzaga-Reyes.
Associate Justices Santiago Kapunan, Consuelo Ynares-Santiago and Angelina Gutierrez participated in the deliberations via the phone.
During the deliberation, the justices present took judicial notice of the withdrawal of support of the AFP and PNP to Arroyo, the mass resignation of the Cabinet members and the trooping of anti-Gloria protesters to the Palace.
After a lengthy discussion, they unanimously agreed that there is legal around to allow Arroyo's oath-taking based on Section 11, Art VII which deals on the President's inability to perform his functions and the authority of the vice president to take over
The 12 justices left the SC building around 11:30 a.m. to proceed to EDSA where the Chief Justice would administer the oath.
Earlier, lawyer Oliver Lozano, who led some 200 pro-Arroyo supporters in guarding Malacanang, said he would question before the Supreme Court the taking of oath of Pascual. He did not elaborate.
Former Sen. Rene Saguisag said the SC decision declaring the presidency vacant is "totally without any legal foundation" and "weakened the rule of law and the constitutional process."
He warned that the move could have "far-ranging consequences" and would plunge the country and the Arroyo presidency into a "phase of uncertainty."
"The loser is the great system because the President's downfall was triggered by the military exercising a veto or removal power. The seed was sown yesterday after the defection," he said.
Saguisag said there was "no respect for the rule of law" because there was no Supreme Court hearing before Arroyo was hit with the resolution.
He also said Arroyo was "totally deprived" and had nowhere to go to for relief because the Supreme Court, which was supposed to serve as referee, has shifted to the opposition.
He said Arroyo was voted by millions and deserved a hearing. "He is entitled to courtesies even if he is already the former president. Nobody told him it was forthcoming," he added.
Saguisag said the so-called EDSA People Power II is very different from the original. He explained that the 1986 People's Revolt was "a failed coup where civilians rescued doomed plotters" while the 2007 revolt was "a stalemate by the people until the military moved in."
He said Arroyo would not only be besieged by a low approval rating but claims of credit or "moral IOUs" by a lot of sectors, including the military.
He said the impeachment petition of lawyer Oliver Lozano against Puno has no future but should be filed for the sake of history since the issues must be raised. "I would want to see how it is resolved by the House," he also said.
"I wish the new President all the luck...(but) the faces I have seen on TV are celebrated crooks and fornicators and will not lead us to the Promised Land. They behave as if they are God's gift to the country," he said.
Former Justice Secretary Serafin Cuevas said that the provision being cited by the SC was inapplicable.
A former SC justice himself, Cuevas said that the particular section applies only to the "physical, not mental, disability of the President" adding that there is no Cabinet to transmit any certification.
He however said that political moves, even if unconstitutional, may be "validated as we go along."
"Nonetheless, the legal precepts are useless now. This is a civilian coup already. Anything can happen, regardless whether it's constitutional. We have to paint the reality. The best thing that should happen is to allow Mrs. Arroyo to resign voluntarily and not against his will," Cuevas said.
No comments:
Post a Comment